It's a definite vote for General Custer from me; he looks like the sort of fellow that I could follow to the ends of the earth...or even on an 'adventure' on the North American Plains.....
There is something peculiarly out-of-scale about the bugler: bugle, hat and pistol are all far too large. I can see the virtues of the painting style when this figure is seen at a distance, but I'm less sure about it when viewed close up.
The painting on Custer however looks very good !!